Guess the Sound

From OAPedia.com

Guess the Sound is an Opie and Anthony bit where O&A play an audio clip and invite listeners to guess what's happening in the clip. The clip is usually of something horrific or disgusting, as are the listeners' guesses.

One listener ended up guessing a particular sound correctly, and was berated by Opie for ruining the bit, telling him that the object of the bit was to give ridiculous answers and not to actually guess what the sound is. Jim Norton then pointed out how Opie got mad at a listener for guessing the sound, even though the bit is called "Guess the Sound". Opie then pointed out that berating the listener for spoiling the bit was actually part of the bit, which led to everyone goofing on Opie's acting when he berated the listener.